The global nutraceutical and supplement industry exceeds $400 billion annually, yet businesses selling vitamins, supplements, and health products routinely face payment processing rejection. If Stripe, Square, or PayPal has rejected your supplement business, you're not alone. Here's why it happens and how to solve it.
Why Nutraceutical & Supplement Businesses Are High-Risk
1. Historical High Chargeback Rates
The supplement industry has traditionally experienced elevated dispute rates due to:
- Subscription billing models: Customers forget about recurring charges
- Free trial offers: Confusing terms lead to unexpected charges
- Results expectations: Customers dispute when products don't deliver claimed benefits
- Impulse purchases: Buyer remorse after late-night infomercial purchases
- Aggressive marketing: Overpromised results creating disappointment
2. FDA Regulatory Concerns
Payment processors worry about businesses making prohibited health claims:
- Unapproved disease treatment claims
- Unsubstantiated benefit statements
- Structure/function claims without proper disclaimers
- Drug claims for dietary supplements
3. Product Safety Liability
Processors assess risk from:
- Adverse event reports
- Contamination or adulteration incidents
- Unregulated ingredient concerns
- Manufacturing quality issues
Real Example: A legitimate vitamin subscription service with GMP-certified manufacturing and FDA-compliant labeling was rejected by Stripe and Square despite having a 0.6% chargeback rate and $4M in annual revenue. After partnering with a specialized supplement processor, they've been processing $350K/month for over 18 months without issues.
Supplement Payment Processing Solutions
Option 1: Specialized Supplement Processors
Processors like SecureMerchant specialize in nutraceuticals:
- ✓ High approval rates (75-90% for compliant businesses)
- ✓ Fast settlements (5 seconds vs 7-30 days)
- ✓ Industry expertise in supplement compliance
- ✓ Subscription billing support
- ✓ Transparent pricing (typically 4-6%)
Requirements for Approval
Manufacturing Documentation
- GMP certification
- Certificate of Analysis (COA)
- Third-party testing results
- Manufacturing agreements
Regulatory Compliance
- FDA-compliant labeling
- No disease claims
- Proper disclaimers
- Substantiation for claims
Website Requirements
- Professional design with SSL
- FDA disclaimer visible
- Clear subscription terms
- Easy cancellation process
- Contact information
Reducing Chargebacks
1. Clear Subscription Terms
- Display terms prominently
- Require explicit opt-in
- Send reminder emails
- Easy cancellation
2. Honest Marketing
- Realistic expectations
- Avoid miracle claims
- Proper disclaimers
3. Excellent Customer Service
- Multiple contact methods
- Quick response times
- Generous return policy
SecureMerchant for Supplements
- 75-90% approval rate
- 5-second settlement
- Subscription billing support
- FDA compliance expertise
- 24-hour approval
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Making prohibited health claims
- Hidden subscription terms
- Aggressive free trial tactics
- Poor product quality
- Inadequate customer service
Ready to Accept Payments?
Join hundreds of supplement companies processing with SecureMerchant.
Start Your Application